← Back
The Gospel Coalition October 5, 2026 10m

Churches Need to Decide How They Will (and Will Not) Use AI

Read full transcript 9 segments
  1. I would like to start, if I I would like to start, if I may, with a scenario that may, with a scenario that may, with a scenario that I would like you I would like you I would like you both to respond to. both to respond to. both to respond to. Imagine that it is 2028 Imagine that it is 2028 Imagine that it is 2028 . And we're in a pretty . And we're in a pretty . And we're in a pretty typical typical typical evangelical church evangelical church , let's say 300 people, a , let's say 300 people, a , let's say 300 people, a couple of pastors, a couple of pastors, a couple of pastors, a small staff, and small staff, and small staff, and they're calling you to they're calling you to they're calling you to give them advice give them advice give them advice on AI. They are already on AI. They are already on AI. They are already using AI using AI using AI for for for sermon preparation, in children's sermon preparation, in children's sermon preparation, in children's curriculum, curriculum, curriculum, and for graphics. And yes, and for graphics. And yes, and for graphics. And yes, several small several small several small group leaders are already group leaders are already group leaders are already relying on AI relying on AI relying on AI to compose to compose to compose discussion questions. And discussion questions. And , you know, if , you know, if , you know, if you ask them in you ask them in you ask them in private, private, private, some church members will some church members will some church members will say, "Look, I say, "Look, I say, "Look, I should ask my should ask my should ask my small group for small group for small group for prayer, but honestly prayer, but honestly prayer, but honestly , it's easier to pour out my , it's easier to pour out my , it's easier to pour out my soul to an AI chatbot on your soul to an AI chatbot on your soul to an AI chatbot on your phone because it phone because it phone because it never never never gets tired, it never gets tired, it never gets tired, it never judges, and it always judges, and it always judges, and it always responds instantly." responds instantly." And the elders of this And the elders of this church don't want church don't want church don't want to act too harshly, to act too harshly, to act too harshly, but they also don't but they also don't but they also don't want to blindly want to blindly want to blindly get involved in something that get involved in something that get involved in something that could be harmful could be harmful could be harmful to the community. So they to the community. So they to the community. So they ask you, " ask you, " Listen, can Listen, can Listen, can you help us with some you help us with some you help us with some simple principles?"

  2. simple principles?" simple principles?" What should our What should our What should our principles be regarding AI as a principles be regarding AI as a principles be regarding AI as a church? So, standing church? So, standing church? So, standing in this church in 2028 in this church in 2028 , what will you say to these , what will you say to these , what will you say to these elders? What elders? What elders? What first principle would you first principle would you first principle would you suggest to suggest to suggest to help them help them help them navigate this navigate this navigate this situation? situation? situation? Yes, thank you, Chris. I'll Yes, thank you, Chris. I'll Yes, thank you, Chris. I'll start by going a little further away start by going a little further away start by going a little further away from your from your from your question and into the question and into the question and into the script itself. I would script itself. I would script itself. I would definitely caution definitely caution definitely caution the group of elders about the group of elders about the group of elders about using AI in using AI in sermon preparation in general, as sermon preparation in general, as well as in researching well as in researching well as in researching sermon materials. In sermon materials. In sermon materials. In my opinion, it is critically my opinion, it is critically my opinion, it is critically important to important to important to immerse yourself in the immerse yourself in the immerse yourself in the text when text when text when preparing a sermon preparing a sermon , and to do so with , and to do so with , and to do so with your whole being— your whole being— mind, body, and mind, body, and mind, body, and spirit. So I think spirit. So I think spirit. So I think AI can be AI can be AI can be useful in finding useful in finding useful in finding additional additional additional materials that materials that materials that may not be in may not be in may not be in your physical your physical your physical library, but I would library, but I would library, but I would strongly advise strongly advise strongly advise caution. After all, a caution. After all, a caution. After all, a sermon is not sermon is not sermon is not just content. This is just content. This is just content. This is content passed content passed content passed through a person.

  3. through a person. So if you So if you rely too much rely too much rely too much on AI to prepare on AI to prepare on AI to prepare sermons, you sermons, you sermons, you risk losing risk losing risk losing the emotion, the stories, the the emotion, the stories, the the emotion, the stories, the personality, and personality, and personality, and other things like that. The other things like that. The other thing I would other thing I would say, as a say, as a say, as a broad principle, is that broad principle, is that I don't think I don't think I don't think Christians should Christians should Christians should use AI use AI use AI as a surrogate or as a surrogate or as a surrogate or substitute for relationships. substitute for relationships. So, that would be the first So, that would be the first of my three simple of my three simple of my three simple filters. Um, so that would be the filters. Um, so that would be the filters. Um, so that would be the first filter. The first filter. The first filter. The second filter, and I second filter, and I second filter, and I took these two terms from took these two terms from took these two terms from Andy Crouch. Um, he Andy Crouch. Um, he Andy Crouch. Um, he didn't apply them to didn't apply them to didn't apply them to AI, but I will. And AI, but I will. And AI, but I will. And Andy Crouch is essentially Andy Crouch is essentially Andy Crouch is essentially saying that there are two kinds of saying that there are two kinds of saying that there are two kinds of work. Um, there is labor work. Um, there is labor and there is hard, and there is hard, and there is hard, exhausting work exhausting work . So, hard work . So, hard work . So, hard work can be directly linked can be directly linked can be directly linked to the Fall, and to the Fall, and to the Fall, and work is part of a work is part of a work is part of a creative or creative or creative or cultural mandate. cultural mandate. So I think So I think overall it's probably a overall it's probably a overall it's probably a good use of good use of good use of time to apply time to apply time to apply AI to tedious AI to tedious AI to tedious work. And, as a general rule, you work. And, as a general rule, you work. And, as a general rule, you shouldn't shouldn't shouldn't use AI use AI use AI for creative work or for for creative work or for for creative work or for something that is part of a something that is part of a something that is part of a creative or creative or creative or cultural mandate.

  4. cultural mandate. cultural mandate. But could you But could you But could you clarify this clarify this clarify this distinction? So, on a distinction? So, on a distinction? So, on a typical day, what is typical day, what is typical day, what is work in my life, work in my life, work in my life, and what is and what is and what is drudgery? drudgery? Yeah, that brings us back Yeah, that brings us back to that to that to that Supreme Court question: "Hey Supreme Court question: "Hey , how do you define , how do you define , how do you define pornography?" You know, a pornography?" You know, a pornography?" You know, a Supreme Supreme Supreme Court justice said, "I'll Court justice said, "I'll Court justice said, "I'll know it when know it when know it when I see it." I think we I see it." I think we I see it." I think we instinctively, on an instinctively, on an instinctively, on an intuitive level, intuitive level, intuitive level, know the difference between know the difference between know the difference between drudgery drudgery drudgery and work. So when and work. So when and work. So when we see things that are not we see things that are not relational in nature, and where we are relational in nature, and where we are not disrespecting anyone by not disrespecting anyone by not disrespecting anyone by doing something doing something doing something electronically or electronically or electronically or through technology through technology , instead of , instead of , instead of doing it with our own doing it with our own doing it with our own minds, thoughts, and minds, thoughts, and minds, thoughts, and all our wisdom all our wisdom all our wisdom that goes into it that goes into it that goes into it . So, I . So, I . So, I think things that think things that think things that fall under the fall under the fall under the creative and cultural creative and cultural creative and cultural mandate often mandate often mandate often require wisdom. And require wisdom. And require wisdom. And wisdom is something that wisdom is something that wisdom is something that I'm not sure the I'm not sure the I'm not sure the great great great language models have, because language models have, because language models have, because maybe it's maybe it's maybe it's self-definition, a self-definition, a self-definition, a tautology, but for tautology, but for tautology, but for me wisdom me wisdom me wisdom is inherently is inherently is inherently embodied. Therefore, I am not embodied. Therefore, I am not embodied. Therefore, I am not sure that AI will sure that AI will ever be able to ever be able to ever be able to possess wisdom.

  5. possess wisdom. OK. So this is the OK. So this is the difference between, let's say, the difference between, let's say, the difference between a map—and difference between a map—and I'll talk about I'll talk about I'll talk about this later—but the this later—but the this later—but the difference between a map and difference between a map and difference between a map and being in the being in the being in the place itself. So I'll place itself. So I'll place itself. So I'll leave that for a leave that for a leave that for a later part of later part of later part of the interview. The third the interview. The third the interview. The third filter for me, I filter for me, I filter for me, I got it from James got it from James got it from James Kelly from FaithTech. AI is at its Kelly from FaithTech. AI is at its Kelly from FaithTech. AI is at its best when best when best when it tries to it tries to it tries to emulate the emulate the emulate the communicative communicative communicative attributes of God. This is what attributes of God. This is what attributes of God. This is what we know about God we know about God we know about God from creation: knowledge, from creation: knowledge, from creation: knowledge, wisdom, wisdom, wisdom, righteousness, goodness, righteousness, goodness, righteousness, goodness, mercy, that kind of mercy, that kind of mercy, that kind of thing. These are thing. These are thing. These are attributes of God that attributes of God that attributes of God that humans also possess. humans also possess. AI is the worst and AI is the worst and should not be should not be should not be used used used when it tries when it tries when it tries to reflect or to reflect or to reflect or imitate the imitate the imitate the uncommunicable uncommunicable uncommunicable attributes of God. So attributes of God. So attributes of God. So these are things like the these are things like the these are things like the aseity of God, the aseity of God, the aseity of God, the self-being of God, self-being of God, self-being of God, the immutability of God, the the immutability of God, the the immutability of God, the fact that God does not fact that God does not fact that God does not change, change, change, the infinity of God, the infinity of God, the infinity of God, his simplicity, and his simplicity, and his simplicity, and of course all the "all-".

  6. of course all the "all-". of course all the "all-". That is, omnipotent, That is, omnipotent, That is, omnipotent, omniscient, omniscient, omniscient, omnipresent. And so, omnipresent. And so, omnipresent. And so, you know, these are the three you know, these are the three you know, these are the three filters that I filters that I filters that I ask myself: Is this a ask myself: Is this a ask myself: Is this a reduction in the reduction in the reduction in the relationship? Do relationship? Do relationship? Do I use it for I use it for I use it for work or heavy work or heavy work or heavy work? And am work? And am work? And am I using this I using this I using this technology in a way technology in a way technology in a way that is consistent with the that is consistent with the that is consistent with the communicative communicative communicative attributes of God, rather than the attributes of God, rather than the attributes of God, rather than the incommunicable ones? incommunicable ones? incommunicable ones? So, those are the three filters So, those are the three filters So, those are the three filters I use. And I use. And I use. And if you pass those if you pass those if you pass those three filters, you know, I three filters, you know, I three filters, you know, I think in 90% of think in 90% of scenarios, you're probably scenarios, you're probably scenarios, you're probably safe. So those are the safe. So those are the safe. So those are the three filters that I three filters that I three filters that I use every time use every time use every time before I decide to, before I decide to, before I decide to, you know, type in a query. you know, type in a query. you know, type in a query. This is extremely This is extremely This is extremely useful. We all useful. We all useful. We all need something ready, need something ready, need something ready, right? We right? We right? We need to need to need to start somewhere, and this is a very start somewhere, and this is a very start somewhere, and this is a very useful useful useful starting point. Keith, do starting point. Keith, do starting point. Keith, do you want to add anything you want to add anything you want to add anything to what to what to what Mike just shared? Mike just shared? Mike just shared? Yes, what Mike said Yes, what Mike said Yes, what Mike said about wisdom, I about wisdom, I about wisdom, I agree with him, that agree with him, that agree with him, that wisdom is embodied. wisdom is embodied. wisdom is embodied. And, of course, from a biblical And, of course, from a biblical And, of course, from a biblical perspective, wisdom perspective, wisdom perspective, wisdom begins with the begins with the begins with the fear of the Lord.

  7. fear of the Lord. fear of the Lord. So, answering the So, answering the So, answering the question of whether question of whether question of whether AI has wisdom, I would AI has wisdom, I would AI has wisdom, I would say: "Well, in that say: "Well, in that say: "Well, in that respect—no." Can respect—no." Can respect—no." Can it be used it be used it be used to impart to impart to impart wisdom received wisdom received wisdom received from someone who is from someone who is from someone who is incarnate and fears the incarnate and fears the incarnate and fears the Lord? Perhaps. But Lord? Perhaps. But Lord? Perhaps. But as for AI itself being as for AI itself being as for AI itself being wise and being a source of wise and being a source of wise and being a source of wisdom, I would say, wisdom, I would say, wisdom, I would say, "No." When I thought about "No." When I thought about "No." When I thought about this scenario, I this scenario, I this scenario, I wished the call wished the call wished the call for help for help for help had come a little had come a little had come a little earlier because they had earlier because they had earlier because they had already started already started already started using AI using AI using AI in in in sermon preparation, curriculum development, sermon preparation, curriculum development, etc. And while I etc. And while I may not tell them may not tell them may not tell them this now, it will be on this now, it will be on this now, it will be on my mind in terms of what my mind in terms of what the thinking behind the thinking behind these decisions is, because these decisions is, because these decisions is, because it has set an it has set an it has set an example for the example for the example for the community to some extent. So I would, I would be community to some extent. So I would, I would be community to some extent. So I would, I would be worried about that. worried about that. And I would say, and this And I would say, and this echoes what echoes what echoes what Mike was talking about, Mike was talking about, Mike was talking about, we shouldn't we shouldn't we shouldn't rely on AI or rely on AI or rely on AI or other mechanisms to do what other mechanisms to do what God created God created God created us to do, to need us to do, to need us to do, to need other people. And that's why other people. And that's why other people. And that's why this relational this relational this relational aspect is critically aspect is critically aspect is critically important. And you know, important. And you know, important. And you know, often the way we often the way we often the way we approach these approach these approach these issues, especially in issues, especially in issues, especially in pastoral pastoral pastoral ministry, comes down ministry, comes down ministry, comes down to, "Well, will to, "Well, will to, "Well, will using AI help me using AI help me using AI help me cut down on cut down on cut down on sermon preparation, help me sermon preparation, help me sermon preparation, help me deal with some of the, deal with some of the, deal with some of the, you know, mundane and

  8. you know, mundane and you know, mundane and not always pleasant not always pleasant not always pleasant things, like things, like things, like answering letters, answering letters, answering letters, etc." And, um, one of the etc." And, um, one of the etc." And, um, one of the things I would really things I would really things I would really recommend to this recommend to this recommend to this group—I recently group—I recently group—I recently read an essay by someone read an essay by someone read an essay by someone named David Kneeland. named David Kneeland. It's called "Why It's called "Why Pastors Should Question Pastors Should Question Pastors Should Question AI AI AI for the Sake of Their Souls." In for the Sake of Their Souls." In for the Sake of Their Souls." In this essay, he shows this essay, he shows that questions like that questions like that questions like “how will AI help me “how will AI help me “how will AI help me become more effective and become more effective and become more effective and precise in my precise in my precise in my pastoral pastoral pastoral ministry” are ministry” are ministry” are distracting distracting distracting because they prevent us because they prevent us , or could prevent us, from , or could prevent us, from , or could prevent us, from asking more important asking more important asking more important questions, such as: questions, such as: questions, such as: how might my use of how might my use of how might my use of this this this hinder the hinder the hinder the formation of virtues and formation of virtues and formation of virtues and fruits of the spirit in my fruits of the spirit in my fruits of the spirit in my life, such as life, such as life, such as patience, patience, patience, perseverance, etc. perseverance, etc.

  9. So, um, those are some So, um, those are some things I would say, and things I would say, and things I would say, and I would add that any I would add that any I would add that any discussion or discussion or discussion or reflection on how we reflection on how we reflection on how we use AI in use AI in use AI in the church or in our the church or in our the church or in our personal lives personal lives personal lives needs to be deeply needs to be deeply needs to be deeply rooted in a rich, rooted in a rich, rooted in a rich, broad, and profound broad, and profound broad, and profound teaching about humanity. And, teaching about humanity. And, teaching about humanity. And, of course, this must of course, this must of course, this must be preceded by a thorough and be preceded by a thorough and be preceded by a thorough and sound teaching about sound teaching about sound teaching about God. But, um, these are the God. But, um, these are the God. But, um, these are the things I would things I would things I would strongly advise them to strongly advise them to strongly advise them to consider. consider. This is incredibly This is incredibly useful. I think what useful. I think what useful. I think what really kept me really kept me really kept me grounded in grounded in grounded in reality was what reality was what reality was what you just said, Keith, you just said, Keith, you just said, Keith, it was the reminder that it was the reminder that any work any work any work done through us is done through us is done through us is also work also work also work done in us. So done in us. So done in us. So when I write a sermon when I write a sermon , it's not just the result , it's not just the result , it's what it does , it's what it does , it's what it does to me. It's how it to me. It's how it to me. It's how it shapes and changes me, shapes and changes me, shapes and changes me, and makes me a person and makes me a person who can, you know, who can, you know, who can, you know, take care of the flock. take care of the flock. take care of the flock. Um, and one of the dangers of Um, and one of the dangers of Um, and one of the dangers of AI is perhaps that AI is perhaps that AI is perhaps that we we we focus only on focus only on focus only on the work that is being done the work that is being done the work that is being done through us and through us and through us and forget about the work forget about the work forget about the work that is being done in us. Um that is being done in us. Um , and biblically speaking, I , and biblically speaking, I , and biblically speaking, I would even venture to would even venture to would even venture to say that it is a work say that it is a work say that it is a work of equal, if not of equal, if not of equal, if not greater, importance.

Summary

This transcript explores how an evangelical church should navigate the growing integration of artificial intelligence in ministry and personal spiritual life by 2028. The discussion addresses practical church applications like sermon preparation, children's curriculum, and the rising trend of individuals using AI chatbots as substitutes for human connection and prayer. The speaker cautions against over-relying on AI for sermon creation, emphasizing deep personal immersion in the text, and establishes a foundational principle that technology should never serve as a surrogate for authentic relationships.

View original episode ↗